Best Desserts in Gilmer, TX
Gilmer isn't a dessert destination on the level of New Orleans or Paris, but we've got sweet treats that hit the spot. From homemade ice cream crafted with love to fresh-baked pies that sell out by noon, here's where to satisfy your sweet tooth in East Texas.
Quick Comparison
| Spot | Must-Try Sweet | Style | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Uncle Joe's Coffee | Homemade ice cream, frappes | Fun, creative, local | Ice cream, unique treats |
| Eagle's Nest Cafe | Fresh-baked pies, homemade rolls | From-scratch kitchen | Classic desserts, weekend brunch |
| Duran's Italian | Tiramisu, Italian desserts | Italian restaurant | After-dinner treat |
| La Finca | Fried ice cream, sopapillas | Tex-Mex classic | Post-fajita indulgence |
Uncle Joe's Coffee
Must-try: Homemade ice cream, specialty frappes, creative treats
Uncle Joe's isn't just coffee—it's a dessert destination. Their homemade ice cream is made in-house with real ingredients, and the frappes are thick, creamy, and indulgent. The "Rock Your Socks" energy drinks and bubble tea round out a menu that's as fun as it is sweet.
"Made with Love and Positivity!"
Insider tip: The homemade ice cream flavors rotate. Ask what's fresh before you order.
Eagle's Nest Cafe
Must-try: Fresh-baked pies, homemade rolls (sweet enough to be dessert) Phone: (903) 806-6748 Hours: Tue–Fri 6:00 AM–3:00 PM, Sat 7:00 AM–2:00 PM
Eagle's Nest bakes their pies fresh every morning. We're talking flaky crusts, seasonal fillings, and the kind of slices that make you close your eyes on the first bite. The homemade rolls are borderline dessert too—buttery, slightly sweet, and perfect with a cup of coffee.
Insider tip: Get there before 10 AM on Saturdays. The pies sell out fast, and once they're gone, they're gone.
La Finca Mexican Food Restaurant
Must-try: Fried ice cream, sopapillas Phone: (903) 843-5355
La Finca offers the classic Tex-Mex dessert lineup. The fried ice cream is crispy on the outside, cold and creamy on the inside—exactly what you want after a plate of fajitas. The sopapillas come with honey for drizzling.
Insider tip: Split a fried ice cream after your meal. It's big enough for two, especially after a full dinner.
Duran's Italian Pizza and Pasta
Must-try: Tiramisu, Italian desserts Location: On the square
Duran's offers traditional Italian desserts to cap off your meal. The tiramisu is the standout—layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers, mascarpone cream, and cocoa. It's the most elegant dessert option in Gilmer.
Insider tip: Save room. The portions are generous, and the tiramisu is worth the extra calories.
Donut Shops
For a quick sweet fix, Gilmer has three donut shops:
Insider tip: All three open early (5–6 AM). The best selection is before 9 AM.
Dessert by the Numbers
| Item | Typical Price |
|---|---|
| Homemade ice cream | $4–6 |
| Slice of pie | $5–7 |
| Fried ice cream | $6–8 |
| Tiramisu | $7–9 |
| Donut | $1–2 |
| Frappe/Smoothie | $5–7 |
Frequently Asked Questions
Where's the best ice cream in Gilmer? Uncle Joe's. It's homemade, rotating flavors, and genuinely good.
Who has the best pie? Eagle's Nest Cafe bakes theirs fresh every morning. Get there early.
Can I get dessert after dinner? La Finca (fried ice cream), Duran's (tiramisu), and Uncle Joe's (ice cream) are all open during dinner hours.
Are there any bakeries in Gilmer? Czech Please Microbakery is the standout for bread and pastries. Check their limited hours before you go.
Last updated: July 2026