Best Pizza in Gilmer, TX
Pizza in a small East Texas town? You bet. Gilmer might not be Naples or New York, but we've got options that go way beyond chain delivery. Whether you want a proper Italian-style pie on the historic square, a house-made pizza at a sports bar, or something to feed the family on a Friday night, Gilmer's pizza scene has you covered.
Quick Comparison
| Spot | Must-Try | Style | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Duran's Italian | Pizza, lasagna, chicken piccata | Italian restaurant, square location | Date night, sit-down dinner |
| Open Range Bar & Grill | House pizza, Black Angus steak | Sports bar, live music | Groups, beer with pizza |
Duran's Italian Pizza and Pasta
Must-try: Pizza, lasagna, chicken piccata, chicken marsala, shrimp scampi Location: On the square in downtown Gilmer
Duran's is the closest thing Gilmer has to a traditional Italian restaurant, and it's right on the historic square. Ninety percent of the people who've eaten here love it—myself included. I've had the lasagna and the pizza, and both are quite good. Not the best Italian I've ever had, but certainly better than most small-town options and probably better than you were expecting to find on the square in Gilmer.
The menu covers the Italian classics: pizza with fresh toppings, hearty lasagna, chicken piccata in a lemon butter sauce, chicken marsala with mushrooms, and shrimp scampi over pasta.
Insider tip: It's the best date-night option in Gilmer if Italian sounds good. The square location gives you a reason to walk around after dinner.
Open Range Bar & Grill
Must-try: House-made pizza, 1855 Black Angus burgers Phone: (903) 680-0539 Website: openrangebarandgrill.com
Open Range isn't just a steakhouse—they make their pizza in-house too. The crust is handmade, the toppings are generous, and the atmosphere is pure East Texas fun. Live music, a full bar, pool tables, and axe throwing lanes mean you can make a whole evening out of a pizza order.
This is where you go when half your group wants pizza and the other half wants steak or burgers. The menu covers everyone.
Insider tip: Call ahead on live music nights. The place packs out, and tables go fast.
What About Chain Pizza?
If you're looking for delivery or carryout, Gilmer has the standard options: Domino's, Pizza Hut, and Little Caesars are all in town. They do the job when you need pizza fast and cheap.
But if you want pizza worth talking about, Duran's and Open Range are where the locals go.
Pizza by the Numbers
| Item | Typical Price |
|---|---|
| Cheese pizza (large) | $12–16 |
| Specialty pizza (large) | $16–22 |
| Pizza + pasta combo | $20–26 |
| Beer (draft) | $4–6 |
Frequently Asked Questions
Who has the best pizza in Gilmer? Duran's for traditional Italian-style pizza in a sit-down setting. Open Range for a bar pie with entertainment.
Does Duran's deliver? Call and ask—small-town restaurants change their policies seasonally. Most locals pick up or dine in.
Can I get pizza late at night in Gilmer? Your best bet is Domino's or Pizza Hut for late delivery. Duran's and Open Range close earlier.
Is Open Range family-friendly? Yes, though the bar atmosphere is more adult-oriented in the evenings. Earlier dinner hours are fine for families.
Last updated: July 2026